Agreement with a sleep lab, stage by stage
Cohen’s kappa against polysomnography, 30 seconds at a time: 0 is chance, 1 is perfect. Higher is better. 62 adults, independent study, 2025.
- Apple0.53 · Series 8
- Fitbit0.42 · Fitbit Sense
- WHOOP0.37 · WHOOP 4.0
- Garmin0.21 · Vivosmart 4
- OuraNot tested
- SamsungNot tested
- PixelNot tested
- PolarNot tested
Apple Watch agreed with the lab best in the largest independent study. Oura wasn’t in it; in a smaller Oura-funded study it edged Apple Watch (0.65 vs 0.60), and a 2026 lab comparison put Oura, WHOOP’s newer algorithm and Apple Watch in the top tier, with Garmin behind. These are older models — algorithms improve — but the order has held across studies.
Schyvens et al., SLEEP Advances, 2025, n=62; Robbins et al., Sensors, 2024, n=35, Oura-funded; Quantified Scientist & Univ. of Salzburg, 2026 preprint, n=18.