# WHOOP vs Garmin vs Apple Watch vs Oura — what each one actually measures

> Eight fitness trackers side by side: what each measures, how close it gets to a sleep lab or ECG in independent studies, what it costs, and what owners say. Tell it what you want and it ranks them.

Source: https://splyt.fit/wearables

Pick any of eight trackers and see them side by side: the sensors inside, what they track, how they did against a sleep lab or an ECG, and what they cost.

** WHOOP **

** Apple Watch **

** Garmin **

Model

5.0 · MG band on the Life tier _4 of 9 sensors_

Series 12 · Ultra 4 for 50 h battery _7 of 9 sensors_

Forerunner 970 · also Venu 4, Fenix 9 _7 of 9 sensors_

**5 LEDs, 4 sensors** From a teardown review; WHOOP doesn’t publish the count.

**Always on** Reads every 5 seconds on Series 12.

**Elevate Gen 5** Generation per reviews; Garmin just says Elevate.

**Yes**

**Yes** Not on SE 3.

**Yes**

**MG only** In the MG’s clasp, which comes with the $359 Life tier.

**Yes** Not on SE 3.

**Yes** Not on Forerunner 570 or the CIRQA band.

**Yes**

**Yes**

**Yes**

**No** Uses your phone’s.

**Single-band** Dual-frequency, plus satellite SOS, on Ultra 4.

**Dual-frequency** Fenix 9 Pro inReach adds satellite messaging and SOS.

**No**

**Both**

**Both**

**No**

**No**

**No**

**No**

**No**

**No**

**No**

**To 6 m** To 40 m on Ultra 4.

**Fenix 9 only** To 40 m.

**None** Vibrates; everything else is in the app.

**OLED** Up to 2,000 nits; 3,000 on Ultra 4.

**AMOLED**

Yes With a catch No Tap a row for the detail.

WHOOP vs Apple Watch vs Garmin. Made by SPLYT, a workout app that reads all of these. We sell none of them and take no affiliate money. Checked November 19, 2026.

## Every model, up close

Most of these come in more than one version, and the versions differ in more than size. Pick a brand, then a model, to see its finishes, price and what it adds or drops.

[Images: Apple Newsroom](https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2026/09/introducing-apple-watch-series-12-with-the-all-new-health-sensing-system/)

### Apple Watch

Price

From $399 (42 mm, GPS). Cellular from $499; titanium from $699; ceramic from $899.

Sizes

42 mm, 46 mm

Battery

Up to 24 h, 38 h in Low Power

Aluminium

- Dark Bronze
- Light Gold
- Black
- Space Gray

Titanium

- Radiant Gold
- Natural

Ceramic

- Pearl White
- Night Blue
- New health sensor: heart rate every 5 seconds, HRV every 5 minutes, and a daily Readiness score.
- ECG, AFib, hypertension and sleep apnea alerts.
- Standard single-band GPS; depth gauge to 6 m.
- Titanium and ceramic come with cellular only.

No subscription for any health feature. iPhone only.

[Series 12 on the maker’s site](https://www.apple.com/apple-watch-series-12/)

## All eight, against the lab

Every independent study we could find that put these devices next to a sleep lab or a chest ECG. Where a device wasn’t in the study, it says so.

### Agreement with a sleep lab, stage by stage

Cohen’s kappa against polysomnography, 30 seconds at a time: 0 is chance, 1 is perfect. Higher is better. 62 adults, independent study, 2025.

- Apple 0.53 · Series 8
- Fitbit 0.42 · Fitbit Sense
- WHOOP 0.37 · WHOOP 4.0
- Garmin 0.21 · Vivosmart 4
- Oura Not tested
- Samsung Not tested
- Pixel Not tested
- Polar Not tested

Apple Watch agreed with the lab best in the largest independent study. Oura wasn’t in it; in a smaller Oura-funded study it edged Apple Watch (0.65 vs 0.60), and a 2026 lab comparison put Oura, WHOOP’s newer algorithm and Apple Watch in the top tier, with Garmin behind. These are older models — algorithms improve — but the order has held across studies.

[Schyvens et al., SLEEP Advances](https://academic.oup.com/sleepadvances/article/6/2/zpaf021/8090472), 2025, n=62 ; [Robbins et al., Sensors](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11511193), 2024, n=35, Oura-funded ; [Quantified Scientist & Univ. of Salzburg](https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2026/04/09/how-do-garmin-apple-watch-oura-ring-and-whoop-compare-in-sleep-tracking/), 2026 preprint, n=18 .

Calories burned: don’t trust any of them. In Stanford’s test no device came within 20%, and the worst was off by 93%. A 2022 review of 41 Fitbit studies found the same. [The Stanford study](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5491979).

## What owners say Recurring praise and complaints from owner communities and long-term reviews. A summary, not a poll.

### Apple Watch

Series 12 · Ultra 4 for 50 h battery

**419,297** people in Apple’s Heart Study, the test behind its AFib alerts

- Every FDA-cleared feature here (ECG, AFib, hypertension, sleep apnea) with no subscription
- Best all-round smartwatch, with a new daily Readiness score
- About a day of battery on Series 12
- iPhone only

Best for iPhone owners who want one device for health, training and everything else.

### WHOOP

5.0 · MG band on the Life tier

**2.5M+** members, March 2026

- Screenless, comfortable 24/7, about two weeks per charge
- Recovery and Strain give a clear daily answer
- Membership required for everything; the 2025 upgrade fee caused a backlash
- No GPS of its own; ECG and BP only on the $359/yr tier

Best for People who want a daily recovery answer and don’t want a screen.

### Garmin

Forerunner 970 · also Venu 4, Fenix 9

**$2.36B** Garmin fitness revenue in 2025, up 33%

- Two weeks of battery, dual-frequency GPS and offline maps
- The deepest training data here, all free
- Sleep tracking and Body Battery can be off
- Connect+ paywall in 2025 worries owners about what comes next

Best for Runners, cyclists and anyone training for an event.

### Oura Ring

Ring 5

**5.0M** paying members, June 2026

- Most accurate overnight heart rate and HRV in independent testing
- Discreet, comfortable to sleep in, about a week per charge
- Most insights need the membership
- Weak heart rate during exercise; no GPS

Best for Sleep and recovery, without wearing anything on your wrist.

### Galaxy Watch

Watch9 · Ultra 2

**2024** first FDA-authorised sleep apnea feature on a smartwatch

- The most health features on Android, all free
- ECG, sleep apnea and cuff-calibrated blood pressure
- Charge it daily
- The best health features need a Samsung phone

Best for Samsung phone owners who want Apple Watch-level health features.

### Pixel Watch

Pixel Watch 5

**2025** FDA clearance for loss-of-pulse detection

- Polished design and good heart rate, with Fitbit’s health tracking built in
- Loss-of-pulse detection and free satellite SOS
- The Gemini health coach costs $9.99/mo
- Android only; 30–40 hours of battery

Best for Pixel and Android owners who want a smartwatch first.

### Fitbit Air

Air · Edge if you want a screen

**455,699** people in the Fitbit Heart Study

- The cheapest way in, with FDA-cleared AFib alerts
- Screenless, about a week per charge
- The coach and automatic workout recaps need Premium
- The move from Fitbit to Google accounts frustrated owners

Best for Trying a tracker for the price of a month of some memberships.

### Polar Loop

Loop

**H10** Polar’s chest strap is the reference other devices’ HRV was tested against

- A WHOOP-style band with no subscription
- Respected heart-rate sensor and Nightly Recharge
- The Polar Flow app feels dated
- No blood oxygen, no GPS of its own

Best for A screenless recovery band without a membership.

## How this was made

Sensors, features and prices come from each maker’s own pages. Accuracy comes from peer-reviewed studies against polysomnography or ECG, and from independent testers where no study exists, named as such. Owner sentiment is a summary of recurring themes, not a poll. Nothing here is medical advice, and none of these devices diagnoses a condition except where the FDA says it can.

Something wrong or out of date? Email [hello@splyt.fit](mailto:hello@splyt.fit?subject=Wearables%20comparison) and we’ll fix it and say so.

All 42 sources

- [Apple: Watch Series 12, Ultra 4 and SE 3 tech specs.](https://www.apple.com/apple-watch-series-12/specs/)
- [Garmin: Forerunner 970 specs (and the 570, Venu 4, Fenix 9 and CIRQA product pages).](https://www.garmin.com/en-US/p/1462801)
- [Oura: Inside the ring — Oura Ring 5 sensors.](https://ouraring.com/blog/inside-the-ring-oura-ring-5/)
- [Google Store: Pixel Watch 5 tech specs.](https://store.google.com/product/pixel_watch_5_specs)
- [Google Store: Fitbit Air and Fitbit Edge tech specs.](https://store.google.com/us/product/google_fitbit_edge_specs)
- [Polar Loop technical specifications.](https://support.polar.com/e_manuals/polar-loop/polar-loop-user-manual-english/technical-specifications.htm)
- [Samsung: Galaxy Watch9 and Watch Ultra2 specs.](https://www.samsung.com/my/mobile/mobile-phone-buying-guide/galaxy-watch9-watch-ultra2-specs-features/)
- [the5krunner: WHOOP 5.0 and MG sensor specs (WHOOP doesn’t publish them).](https://the5krunner.com/specs/whoop/5-0-mg/)
- [Schyvens et al. (2025). Performance of six consumer sleep trackers vs polysomnography. SLEEP Advances 6(2).](https://academic.oup.com/sleepadvances/article/6/2/zpaf021/8090472)
- [Robbins et al. (2024). Accuracy of three commercial wearables for sleep tracking. Sensors 24(20). Oura-funded.](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11511193)
- [Quantified Scientist & University of Salzburg (2026). Sleep tracking comparison, preprint (summary).](https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2026/04/09/how-do-garmin-apple-watch-oura-ring-and-whoop-compare-in-sleep-tracking/)
- [Dial et al. (2025). Validation of nocturnal resting HR and HRV in consumer wearables. Physiological Reports 13(16).](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12367097)
- [Letter: Accurate comparison of wearables requires contextual equivalence (2025).](https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC12701519/)
- [Shcherbina et al. (2017). Accuracy in wrist-worn sensor-based measurements of HR and energy expenditure. J Pers Med 7(2).](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5491979)
- [Fitbit accuracy meta-analysis (2022). JMIR mHealth 10(4).](https://mhealth.jmir.org/2022/4/e35626)
- [Lambe et al. (2025). Apple Watch VO₂ max validity. PLoS ONE.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40373042/)
- [Garmin VO₂ max in trained runners (2025). European Journal of Applied Physiology.](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00421-025-05923-x)
- [Perez et al. (2019). Apple Heart Study. NEJM 381.](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8112605)
- [Lubitz et al. (2022). Fitbit Heart Study. Circulation 146.](https://www.massgeneral.org/news/press-release/fitness-trackers-may-diagnose-potentially-irregular-heartbeats)
- [Apple: Apple Watch Series 12.](https://www.apple.com/apple-watch-series-12/)
- [DC Rainmaker: Apple Watch Series 12 in-depth review (Oct 2026).](https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2026/10/apple-watch-series12-in-depth-review-worth-upgrade.html)
- [FDA clears Apple Watch hypertension notifications (Sept 2025).](https://cardiovascularbusiness.com/topics/clinical/hypertension/fda-clears-apple-watch-algorithm-detecting-hypertension)
- [ITC closes the Masimo import case (Apr 2026).](https://9to5mac.com/2026/04/17/apple-wins-latest-round-in-masimo-fight-as-itc-closes-apple-watch-import-ban-case/)
- [WHOOP: memberships compared.](https://www.whoop.com/us/en/thelocker/which-membership-is-right-for-you/)
- [WHOOP 5.0 and MG launch (May 2025).](https://www.whoop.com/us/en/press-center/whoop-unveils-5.0-MG/)
- [FDA closes its warning letter over WHOOP Blood Pressure Insights (Jun 2026).](https://www.mobihealthnews.com/news/fda-closes-warning-letter-whoop-blood-pressure-insights-feature)
- [WHOOP Series G and membership count (Mar 2026).](https://news.crunchbase.com/venture/wearable-fitness-tech-ai-whoop-seriesg-funding/)
- [WHOOP upgrade-fee backlash (May 2025).](https://techcrunch.com/2025/05/11/fitness-tracker-whoop-faces-unhappy-customers-over-upgrade-policy)
- [Tom’s Guide: Garmin Forerunner 970 review.](https://www.tomsguide.com/wellness/smartwatches/garmin-forerunner-970-review-my-new-favorite-sports-watch)
- [Garmin Connect+ features and price.](https://www.tomsguide.com/wellness/smartwatches/garmin-launches-a-paywall-here-are-all-the-premium-connect-features-that-will-cost-you-usd6-99-a-month)
- [Garmin FY2025 Form 10-K (fitness segment revenue).](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1121788/000119312526056028/grmn-20251227.htm)
- [Oura: Introducing Oura Ring 5.](https://ouraring.com/blog/introducing-oura-ring-5/)
- [Oura IPO filing (members, retention).](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/05/21/oura-smart-ring-ipo-filing.html)
- [Oura API and membership.](https://support.ouraring.com/hc/en-us/articles/4415266939155-The-Oura-API)
- [Samsung: Galaxy Watch9.](https://www.samsung.com/us/watches/galaxy-watch9/)
- [Samsung: blood pressure and sleep apnea availability in the US.](https://news.samsung.com/us/samsung-blood-pressure-monitoring-feature-available)
- [Google: Pixel Watch 5.](https://blog.google/products-and-platforms/devices/pixel/pixel-watch-5/)
- [Google Health Premium (May 2026).](https://9to5google.com/2026/05/26/google-health-premium/)
- [Google: Fitbit Air.](https://blog.google/products-and-platforms/devices/fitbit/fitbit-air/)
- [Google Health API migration (Fitbit Web API shut down).](https://developers.google.com/health/migration)
- [TechRadar: Polar Loop review.](https://www.techradar.com/health-fitness/fitness-trackers/polar-loop-review)
- [Counterpoint: global smartwatch shipments.](https://counterpointresearch.com/en/insights/global-smartwatch-shipments-market-share)

## Whatever you wear, SPLYT plans the lifting around it.

Apple Watch connects directly, WHOOP links in a tap, and Oura, Garmin and the rest arrive through Apple Health. Free to use.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/id6755893717) Requires iOS 17 · Apple Watch optional, but recommended
